Best Orthopedic Hospitals in NYC 2019

November 4, 2019
Best of Guides

Anytime you’re dealing with a serious medical concern, stress levels are quite high, and this is only exacerbated by how difficult it can be to find the right doctor and hospital to see. Whether you’re an athlete dealing with a serious injury or just struggling with ongoing bone and joint issues, finding the right orthopedic surgeon is absolutely imperative. There are tons of orthopedic hospitals in NYC, but how do you know which one is going to provide you the best care in a timely manner? Our guide to the best orthopedic hospitals in Manhattan is here to help you make the best choice for your health. We’ve given each hospital a score out of 10 based on a number of factors, including wait time, patient outcomes, and reputation of the surgeons or doctors at the hospitals. 

Hospital for Special Surgery, 9/10 

(212) 606-1000, 535 East 70th Street, New York, NY 10021

Picture of the exterior of Hospital for Special Surgery Orthopedic Center in Manhattan

The Hospital for Special Surgery is nationally recognized as one of the oldest and best orthopedic hospitals in the country. It is the official hospital of the New York Giants, Mets, Knicks, Red Bulls, the Brooklyn Nets, and the New York Road Runners among many other professional sports organizations. It also ranks higher in general patient experience, advanced technology, and positive patient outcomes than almost any other orthopedic hospital in the country. While you might have to wait a bit to get an appointment, there is no doubt that this is the absolute best hospital in the country to handle a wide range of different orthopedic issues.  Some notable doctors that work for HSS are Dr. David Altchek, Dr. Robert Hotchkiss, and Dr. Bryan Kelly. We’re giving it a 9/10 just because the wait times can be long. 

NYU Langone Orthopedic Hospital, 8/10 

301 E 17th St, New York, NY 10003

(212) 598-6000

Picture of NYU Langone Orthopedic Hospital in Manhattan

The orthopedic hospital at NYU ranks in the top ten orthopedic hospitals in NYC. It provides inpatient and outpatient surgical care for adults, and also has the capability of providing highly specialized care for a number of other orthopedic related concerns. There is also an in-house rehabilitation center, which can help to ease the recovery process. The hospital is one of the largest in New York City, and conveniently located downtown, but as a result suffers a bit from the high volume of patients that come through. While some patients have complained about feeling a bit lost in the shuffle, it is not the overwhelming review.

Manhattan Orthopedic Care, 8/10 

515 Madison Ave #1102, New York, NY 10022

(212) 729-9200

Picture of Manhattan Orthopedic Care Logo

This orthopedic specific clinic specializes in knee and shoulder conditions and is spearheaded by Dr. Armin Tehrany. Dr. Tehrany is considered one of the top orthopedic surgeons in NYC, working as a clinical professor at Mount Sinai School of Medicine and serving on the Board of Directors for the New York State Society of Orthopedic Surgeons. This clinic is also listed in New York magazine and The New York Times as one of the top doctors in New York City. Patients generally report satisfaction with their care, though the wait times can be a bit long.

Lenox Hill Hospital, 7/10

100 E 77th St, New York, NY 10075

(212) 434-2000

Picture of Lenox Hill Hospital on the Upper East Side of Manhattan

Lenox Hill is a very large, high volume hospital on the Upper East Side in New York City and suffers a bit in our ranking because of this. The facilities aren’t as updated and shiny as some of the private practices, but there are benefits that come along with being at larger facility, such as a larger range of medical care and staff on hand. Lenox Hill does, however, have a very widely recognized and respected orthopedics department and a fantastic array of doctors who are skilled at assisting with many different orthopedic concerns. The orthopedic surgery department has been around since 1857, so this facility has a long history of treating patients. The current chairman of the department, Dr. Elliot Hershman, has served as the chief physician of the New York Jets for over 25 years, as well as the New York Islanders. Lenox Hill is also one of the top teaching hospitals in the city. This hospital loses a few points for feedback from patients on their experience.

Mount Sinai Beth Israel, 7/10

281 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10003

(212) 420-2000

Picture of Mount Sinai Beth Israel in Manhattan

Mount Sinai is known for being able to treat a wide range of different orthopedic conditions including joint replacement, tissue tumors, sports medicine, and general orthopedic surgery. They also focus on using minimally invasive procedures to minimize recovery time and scarring. It is ranked as 18th in the country, but 3rd in New York City in adult orthopedics and has many locations throughout the city, which can be immensely helpful in terms of making an appointment and getting to the location, especially if you are in severe pain. Mount Sinai loses a few points because there have been reports of prolonged hospital stays after surgery and a few occurrences of repeated surgeries needed.

New York-Presbyterian Hospital-Columbia and Cornell, 8/10

Multiple locations 


Picture of New York Presbyterian Weill Cornell in Manhattan

New York Presbyterian is ranked #13 in the country for orthopedics. This hospital has the benefit of being associated with two Ivy medical schools–Columbia and Cornell–which helps it to stay on top of the latest medical innovations. It also operates as one of the leading teaching hospitals in the country. This is another large hospital and suffers from a lot of the same complaints that other hospitals struggle with–patient care and attentiveness, doctors who are very busy, and long wait times. US News and World Report also notes that patients are often discharged to other facilities instead of sent home, which has lost it a few points in its ranking. 

New York Bone and Joint Specialists, 8/10

Multiple locations

New York Bone and Join Specialists Logo

New York Bone and Joint specialists are known for being experts in a variety of orthopedic concerns including knee, hip, shoulder, neck, spine, foot, ankle, elbow, and more. The clinic is a great place to start if you are not sure if you will need surgery, as they have many different types of treatments such as physical therapy and sports medicine. If, however, surgery is necessary, they can handle a wide range of complex procedures in house. Each of the doctors have their own specialty and are highly ranked orthopedic surgeons in NYC, so you can rest assured that you are in good hands. There have been quite a few reports of issues with billing at this clinic, so make sure that you get your insurance and all procedures approved before proceeding.

Orthopedic Surgery and Sports Medicine, 9/10 

737 Park Ave #1c, New York, NY 10021, USA

(212) 794-5096

Dr. Michael Glashow in a boxing ring

This clinic is spearheaded by Dr. Jonathan L. Glashow, who was named the #1 orthopedic surgeon in NYC in 2018 by Castle and Connolly. He currently serves as the chief medical officer of both the New Jersey Red Devils and the Philadelphia 76ers. He has over 30 years of experience in the field of orthopedics and serves on many boards around the city. The office also boasts same day or next day appointments. The practice is adept as assisting with care of a wide range of orthopedic issues including shoulders, hips, and knees. His specialty is definitely in assisting athletes recover from injuries buy all types of patients can benefit from his expertise.

New York Orthopedics, 7/10 

Multiple Locations

New York Orthopedics Logo

NY Orthopedics is a state-of-the-art practice with 7 locations all around the city. They have nearly 20 different doctors on staff, each with their own specialty, assuring that you are going to receive the best care. The patient review are generally good and report back mostly good experiences with the overall experience, though there are some concerns about communication and insurance. One other downside is that this clinic doesn’t do the surgery in-house, but will outsource to hospitals in the area. This is a common issue with the private practices, but something to keep in mind when booking surgery with the clinic.

New York Sports and Joints, 7/10 

110 Duane St, New York, NY 10007

(212) 588-1919

New York Sports and Joints Logo

New York Sports and Joints is a clinic that focuses on sports medicine, fractures, trauma, and acute and chronic spinal conditions as well as joint replacement. The clinic focuses on helping to fix bone and joint issues without the use of surgery, but as a multi-disciplinary facility will recommend surgery if necessary. Like some of the other clinics on the list, they partner with nearby hospitals for the actual surgery, so the surgery will not be handled from start to finish by the clinic. This can cause some issues in communication and varied experiences depending on which hospital you are taken to. The surgeries themselves are performed by one of the four board certified surgeons on staff however. There have some reported issues with long wait times, and spending more time with PAs instead of the doctor, which is why this one lost a few points.

NY Spine Care, 9/10 

191-32 Northern Blvd, Flushing, NY 11358

(718) 762-7000

A picture of Dr. Paul Brisson

This clinic, spearheaded by Dr. Paul Brisson who specializes in spinal injuries. The spine is one of the most important and delicate parts of the body, so you want the absolute best when searching for a doctor to operate on it. While the clinic is located in Queens, not Manhattan, it is worth the trek. Dr. Brisson consistently gets great reviews for bed-side manner, taking the time to explain what is going to be done and providing wonderful pre- and post-op care. His clinic does a great job of explaining what options are available, taking non-surgical options first, and guiding you through the surgery if it is deemed necessary. He is ranked as one of the top spinal surgeons in the city. It is a small operation, so you may have to wait a bit to get into see the doctor, but if you are suffering from extreme back pain, it is worth the wait.

Finding just the right doctor and hospital for your issue can be a daunting task, especially in a city as large as New York. Thankfully, New York is home to some of the best orthopedic surgeons in the country, and there are a ton of great options out there to suit your needs. You don’t have to live with the constant pain caused by orthopedic injuries, and while surgery should always be a last resort, it’s important to make an informed decision. We hope that you find this list useful, and remember that you can find more information about all of the doctors right here on Voro.

Katherine Packer

Katherine is a freelance writer specializing in content marketing, blog posts, social media, and copywriting. Since graduating from Sarah Lawrence with a BA in creative writing and theater, she has expanded her writing skills from ultra-specific academic papers and thinly veiled fiction based on her life to more business-oriented copy. She is currently based in Brooklyn.  

Related Posts

Stay in Touch

Thank you! Your submission has been received!

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form